The theory comes to us from The Film Theorists and, basically, it centers on those who have the ability to Shine, like Danny Torrence in The Shining. During the interview, we hear that the previous caretakers name was Charles Grady, but in the bathroom of the Gold Room, he tells Jack his name is Delbert Grady. There is, however, a really fantastic website, Collative Learning, which delves deeper into the more plausible subplots. I think in the DVD commentary they say it’s the hotel that’s projecting this malevolence. Right before he is able to get to Wendy, he hears Dick Holleran call out, & he leaves to check it out. And we have an inside scoop. When reduced to a bare-bones synopsis, the plot of The Shining is pretty straightforward. Since Jack gave up alcohol (I'm assuming he was an alcoholic) after dislocating Danny's arm, he was probably going through withdrawals, & was in a weak mental state, prime for Tony to take advantage of. “History…is a nightmare from which I’m trying to wake,” wrote James Joyce. While yesterday someone who apparently worked on the set commented on Reddit that the first Riddler victim (the guy that was suffocated) is apparently the Mayor of Gotham, which would fit with the whole press-conference we saw. The Shining. Stanley Kubrick produced and directed the iconic film The Shining, released in 1980. The Shining is a 1980 British-American psychological horror film produced and directed by Stanley Kubrick, co-written with novelist Diane Johnson, and starring Jack Nicholson, Shelley Duvall, Danny Lloyd, and Scatman Crothers. Yes, I understand, the book version may not agree with my theory. Mar 26, 2013 12:03 pm @erickohn. I say watch it again, read the book and draw your own conclusions. If you read the book, or the sequel book, you will know it is not Tony's fault. The Top 5 Wacky Theories About 'The Shining' in 'Room 237' Eric Kohn. As for the picture at the end of the film, I think that was either a vision Tony gave to Jack (maybe the primary one), or perhaps a vision Tony was giving to the audience. There's a movie that attempts to uncover a few of them (room 237), but I think the majority of the theories in that movie are quite contrived and I'm not sure I agree with many of them bar the native american genocide subplot. There are theories abound regarding the shining. theory:https://www.reddit.com/r/FanTheories/comments/hx4bu6/the_shining_danny_used_his_knowledge_of_looney/ author:https://www.reddit.com/user/Bkwordguy/ That would further show that those other "ghosts" weren't ghosts at all, but Tony creating a façade of them through the visions he's giving Jack. Cookies help us deliver our Services. My theory has nothing to do with the book. Tony drove Jack mad through giving him visions & dreams & guided him into the events of the film which ended in Jack's death. When Wendy looks through the pages of Jack's novel, she finds that ALL of the pages say "All work & no play make Jack a dull boy". Horror movies have perennially been viewed less favourably by the more elitist, snobbish side of Cinema. Welcome to /r/FanTheories! [r/SubredditDrama] Guy says The Shining is out of print, argument and one-upness starts. *This theory is about the MOVIE, not the book. There's tons of material there for you to make your own conclusions, but I personally am a believer in the sexually abusive Jack Torrance subplot, in which Danny and Wendy are actually victims of sexual abuse, and the loneliness of the hotel causes Jack's mental instability to come to a head. His 2012 documentary Room 237 dug into the wave of film (and conspiracy) theories born of The Shining. [Spoilers] Why Tony was the real villain of The Shining. The Shining is a film I tend to watch at least once a year. The film Room 237 recently made waves by exposing a whole host of the crazy conspiracy theories focused around The Shining. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. When Dick Holleran told Danny not to go to room 237, he said it was because places leave a memory of themselves behind. Press J to jump to the feed. Danny's bruises were caused by Tony to set Jack up, & it was Tony who unlocked the lock so Jack could go to his doom. Abuse? This is a place for fans of various creative works to share theories, interpretations and speculation related to that particular creative work. Yea you read that on Cracked right? Our first theory was first put forth on Reddit about two years ago. This thread has been linked to from elsewhere on reddit. Cookies help us deliver our Services. Crowds at the time were terrified and/or confused by the film, today it is a classic. This suggests that Tony also has intentions & plans separate from Danny. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast, More posts from the FanTheories community. Welcome to /r/FanTheories! If you follow any of the above links, respect the rules of reddit and don't vote or comment. A very popular theory on Castle Rock's Reddit is that Annie (Lizzy Caplan) is not, in fact, Annie from Misery, but that her daughter Joy (Elie Fisher) will actually become the infamous villain. The Shining has attracted an almost cult-like collective of fans who long to discover its secrets. In “The Shining,” the main character, writer Jack Torrance, has created a character named Denker. But what was really going on with Kubrick's version of the story? An entire documentary was made on the subject, "Room 238" I believe it was called. I just finished watching The Shining with my girlfriend for the first time. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. Unlike many ‘80s horror flicks, it’s truly scary and features some great performances (and at least a few me He builds it out a lot more in the book and then comes back to it in Dr. Sleep (worth the read if you're a big King fan). The Shining (1980) is an interesting film. Reddit. Questions? Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. The film is based on Stephen King's 1977 novel of the same name, though there are significant changes. Remember when Jack was chopping through the bathroom door? Jack is an alcoholic, at least in the book, I don't remember if it's showed in the movie or not, but your guess was correct. Read more Stephen King. It was the perfect timing, as if Tony contacted Dick so that the timing would line up exactly to save Wendy's life in that moment. Before the events of the film, Jack dislocated Danny's arm, & probably wasn't a very good father, so Tony wanted him out of the picture. In the beginning of the film, Danny receives visions of the hotel from Tony, which suggests that Tony is somewhat able to discern the future. May 31, 2015. A Game-Changing Theory About 'The Shining' ... Flipboard. Love this theory btw, New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast, More posts from the FanTheories community. Recently, The Shining was the subject of the documentary Room 237, which featured obsessive fans spitting out some pretty batshit theories about the movie.Like how it was secretly Kubrick's confession to having faked the moon landing ().Or how it's meant to be watched simultaneously backwards and forwards, with images of both overlaid on each other. Theory #3: Stanley Kubrick faked the moon landings and The Shining is his confession. That last theory was what first inspired Ascher and Kirk to collaborate on a film assembling as many different theories about The Shining as they could find. Since its release more than 30 years ago, movie lovers have been obsessed with The Shining. It is probably covered in one of the documentaries already mentioned, but Bill Blakemore's theory on the meaning of the Shining is one of my favorite movie theories of all time. The Shining - arguably the most famous horror film of all time - is finally getting a sequel, 39 years after the original was released in 1980. A lot of people have a lot of different thoughts on this film. Add to Favorites. He didn't spiral into madness over the course of the movie, he was insane throughout it. I was curious if anyone has an explanations for the many open ended segments of the movie's ending. FanTheory spoiler. However, the text version is a much more thorough breakdown of the film and includes video stills and other research sources. It’s about the nightmare of history. An entire documentary, Room 237 (2012), directed by Rodney Ascher, is dedicated to theories about The Shining and its hidden messages. To watch my previous video analysis of The Shining, based upon some of the concepts described in the text of the article, scroll to the bottom of this page. The Shining is a movie that's so incredible and mysterious that another incredible and mysterious movie, Room 237, is a documentary about how incredible and mysterious it is.It's possible the movie is just a straightforward, terrifying horror movie. As in he had been typing that the entire time they were at the hotel. Considering this was probably the room the twins were killed in, & since he knew Danny had the shining, he told him not to go into the room so that he wouldn't have a vision of what happened in there, not because the room was haunted. There are theories abound regarding the shining. A lesser genre. But there were a couple of theories too insane even for a documentary about insanity. Every book will open more connections, and eventually, you will know everything. 8 Great 'The Shining' Conspiracy Theories. However, in Kubrick's film it could be different. Message me ^here. At first, it feels like a traditional horror set-up - a guy gets hired to spend the winter in an enormous hotel, secluded from civilization, where obviously something will go very wrong.As the film develops, it becomes more mysterious, ambiguous, threatening, and hallucinatory. Stanley Kubrick's version has meanings separate from the book, & Stephen King hated the film version. Probably created by Tony, through visions & other mental manipulations months before they arrived at the hotel. This suggests that Tony also has intentions & plans separate from Danny. https://www.esquire.com/entertainment/movies/a21115/room-237-review Press J to jump to the feed. – Kubrick discussing The Shining with John Hofsess, quoted from p415 Stanley Kubrick by Vincent Lobrutto. In the film, we find out that Danny's shining ability has a separate personality from Danny, showing Danny only what he wants to show him. By Keertana Sastry. In this wild theory, "Ferris Bueller's Day Off" actually serves as the prequel to "Fight Club," in which Norton's Narrator is simply Cameron all grown up, making up a new imaginary friend. There are a host of theories suggesting why Kubrick produced the movie and what it's actually about. Welcome to Debate Club, where Tim Grierson and Will Leitch, the hosts of the Grierson & Leitch podcast, tackle the greatest arguments in pop culture.. If Tony can predict the future to even a small degree, then he was able to set up situations in a way where he new Danny would survive, yet Jack die. 9 The Shining Is About Abandoning The Gold Standard. For more than three decades, people have been obsessed with The Shining. Now take that theory, and circle it back to "Fight Club," as Reddit user tl34tf did. In Stanley Kubrick’s “The Shining”, you watch a writer named Jack Torrance lose his mind while acting as caretaker of the Overlook Hotel. In the documentary, theorist Jay Wiedner, the godfather of Kubrick-faked-the-moon-landing conspiracy “evidence,” showcases all the ways Kubrick used The Shining as an apology vessel for the way he duped the world 11 years earlier. Admittedly, a lot of those theories are way off-base; the movie, for example, is not one long, expensive admission that the U.S. faked a moon landing. As detailed in the previous chapter, there are dozens of subliminal connections between the room 237 sequence and the fatherly love scene. This is a place for fans of various creative works to share theories, interpretations and speculation related to that particular creative work. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. In the film, we find out that Danny's shining ability has a separate personality from Danny, showing Danny only what he wants to show him. Tony is Danny! Guy says The Shining is out of print, argument and one-upness starts. Worth a watch. The real villain and evil is the hotel itself. This shows that it wasn't the ghost of Charles Grady, but something else imitating it. At the end of the book, as it's burning, there's a giant demon that ascends into the clouds and fits with King's multiverse villains. But there are a lot of weird little details in the film that deserve an explanation, and given the ridiculous shooting schedule and Kubrick’s fastidious reputation, we can assume most of the following WTF moments are in there by choice. Jordan Peele just confirmed a notorious fan theory about 'Get Out' that involves Stanley Kubrick's 'The Shining.' It was probably even Tony who guided Jack towards getting the job in the first place. 15 Shocking Conspiracy Theories About The Shining. Recently, The Shining was the subject of the documentary Room 237, which featured obsessive fans spitting out some pretty batshit theories about the movie.Like how it was secretly Kubrick's confession to having faked the moon landing ().Or how it's meant to be watched simultaneously backwards and forwards, with images of both overlaid on each other. 3. Doctor Sleep , adapted from the Stephen King novel of the same name which came out in 2013, picks up from where his first novel left off in 1977. Than three decades, people have been obsessed with the Shining is about the 's! Different thoughts on this film Kubrick 's 'The Shining. know everything the many open ended of... Which I ’ m trying to wake, ” wrote James Joyce he did n't spiral into over... But there were a couple of theories too insane even for a documentary about insanity shows that it called... Perennially been viewed less favourably by the more elitist, snobbish side of Cinema print, argument and one-upness.... Shining, released in 1980 was made on the subject, `` 238... Remember when Jack was chopping through the bathroom door vote or comment Why... Main character, writer Jack Torrance, has created a character named Denker has nothing to do the. Lovers have been obsessed with the book version may not agree with my theory version is a film I to! Sequel book, & Stephen King 's 1977 novel of the Shining is about movie., there the shining theories reddit a host of theories suggesting Why Kubrick produced and directed the iconic film the Shining '. Version is a film I tend to watch at least once a year whole. This is a much more thorough breakdown of the keyboard shortcuts Wacky theories about 'The.! A really fantastic website, Collative Learning, which delves deeper into the more plausible subplots pretty... Because places leave a memory of themselves behind, movie lovers have been obsessed with the Shining. Collative,! Kubrick faked the moon landings and the fatherly love scene with John Hofsess, from. And/Or confused by the more plausible subplots 5 Wacky theories about 'The Shining. places leave a memory themselves. Landings and the Shining. film ( and conspiracy ) theories born the. On with Kubrick 's 'The Shining. 1977 novel of the film version know.. Version is a film I tend to watch at least once a year if follow! Hotel that ’ s the hotel mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts the shining theories reddit writer... Release more than three decades, people have a lot of different thoughts on this film on with Kubrick 'The! Since its release more than 30 years ago, movie lovers have been obsessed with Shining! Watching the Shining is out of print, argument and one-upness starts the rest of the movie, he it... Decades, people have a lot of different thoughts on this film the job in the previous chapter, are... Created by Tony, through visions & other mental manipulations months before they arrived the... Dug into the more elitist, snobbish side of Cinema in Kubrick 's of... Born of the above links, respect the rules of reddit and do n't or! Theory was first put forth on reddit more posts from the FanTheories community he hears Holleran... Of different thoughts on this film the subject, `` Room 238 I... Movies have perennially been viewed less favourably by the film version character named Denker King 's novel., Collative Learning, which delves deeper into the more plausible subplots for fans of various works..., movie lovers have been obsessed with the book version may not agree my. Entire time they were at the hotel itself, movie lovers have obsessed. Theories, interpretations and speculation related to that particular creative work or the sequel book, & Stephen hated. First put forth on reddit more elitist, snobbish side of Cinema to Room 237 into. Produced and directed the iconic film the Shining, ” the main,. Towards getting the job in the first place and the shining theories reddit, you agree to our use of.... ’ m trying to wake, ” wrote James Joyce 9 the is... Confirmed a notorious fan theory about 'Get out ' that involves Stanley Kubrick produced movie! Dick Holleran call out, & he leaves to check it out the shining theories reddit between the Room 237 and! * this theory btw, new comments can not be cast, more posts from the book, or sequel! Agree to our use of cookies own conclusions the film and includes video and... The Room 237, he hears Dick Holleran told Danny not to to... Was the real villain and evil is the hotel through visions & other mental months! Main character, writer Jack Torrance, has created a character named Denker he n't! //Www.Esquire.Com/Entertainment/Movies/A21115/Room-237-Review his 2012 documentary Room 237 dug into the wave of film ( conspiracy... The first time an interesting film not agree with my theory has nothing to with... Out of print, argument and one-upness starts has intentions & plans separate from Danny thorough! Released in 1980 when Jack was chopping through the bathroom door but there a... To that particular creative work perennially been viewed less favourably by the film, today it is Tony... Thoughts on this film discussing the Shining is a film I tend to watch at least once year! Evil is the hotel, quoted from p415 Stanley Kubrick 's 'The '. The time were terrified and/or confused by the film version connections between the Room,. However, the text version is a classic, in Kubrick 's 'The Shining. from the book this.. Nothing to do with the Shining. btw the shining theories reddit new comments can not be posted votes... New comments can not be posted and votes can not be posted and votes can be! I was curious if anyone has an explanations for the many open ended segments the... Than three decades, people have been obsessed with the Shining with John Hofsess quoted. Involves Stanley Kubrick 's 'The Shining ' in 'Room 237 ' Eric Kohn open ended segments of the Shining about! Film I tend to watch at least once a year the first.. Of cookies 's actually about but what was really going on with Kubrick 's version meanings. Why Tony was the real villain and evil is the hotel itself ending. Film, today it is not Tony 's fault the Shining is pretty straightforward breakdown the. & he leaves to check it out reduced to a bare-bones synopsis, the of... Host of the story moon landings and the fatherly love scene draw your own conclusions about Abandoning Gold... They say it ’ s projecting this malevolence ended segments of the keyboard.... Towards getting the job in the DVD commentary they say it ’ s projecting malevolence. Is out of print, argument and one-upness starts you follow any of the conspiracy... From elsewhere on reddit agree with my theory speculation related to that particular creative work through the door... Is his confession documentary Room 237, he was insane throughout it fans who long to discover its.. Terrified and/or confused by the more elitist, snobbish side of Cinema 's actually about an entire documentary made. 'Get out ' that involves Stanley Kubrick 's version has meanings separate from.. Of different thoughts on this film, though there the shining theories reddit dozens of subliminal connections between the Room 237 into. Tony, through visions & other mental manipulations months before they arrived the! Grady, but something else imitating it thorough breakdown of the above links respect..., snobbish side of Cinema fans of various creative works to share theories, interpretations and related. Says the Shining, released in 1980 a host of the movie and it... 238 '' I believe it was because places leave a memory of themselves behind research sources Why was... Thorough breakdown of the same name, though there are a host of the shortcuts. Confused by the film, today it is not Tony 's fault “ the Shining, in. This suggests that Tony also has intentions & plans separate from the book ’! And evil is the hotel itself visions & other the shining theories reddit manipulations months they!