Have you had issues related to COVID-19 affecting your court case? “We are unable to provide the right kind of care without it,” said Dr. Robert Wachter, chair of the department of medicine at the University of California, San Francisco. The danger of the judge’s order, if followed, is that it might lead to one of the boys not getting medical treatment he needs, said Michelle Mello, a health law and policy professor at Stanford University. At a protest rally in May, just steps away from where he presides over family court, Grendell proclaimed that public health restrictions to contain the pandemic were unconstitutional and “we should be allowed to get back to our lives.” The following month, he testified to state lawmakers in Columbus that health authorities and a “drumbeat” of media coverage had “created an atmosphere of fear” surrounding the virus. In their mostly rural county of about 90,000 people, the judge and his wife have repeatedly made public comments that minimize the health threat of the pandemic, he said. Ohio juvenile court Judge Timothy Grendell has been outspoken about his belief that the COVID-19 pandemic is overblown. This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Hartman told ProPublica that she begged that her two boys not be locked up during a pandemic. In their mostly rural county of about 90,000 people, the judge and his wife have repeatedly made public comments that minimize the health threat of the pandemic, he said. It is highly unusual for a judge to call a litigant in a proceeding directly. The child was administered a COVID-19 test before being admitted and treated during an overnight stay. A doctor subsequently ordered a coronavirus test for one of the boys before admitting him to a children's hospital for severe breathing problems. Ohio juvenile court Judge Timothy Grendell has been outspoken about his belief that the COVID-19 pandemic is overblown. Individuals can use the online calculator to estimate their risk of dying from COVID-19 if they become infected with the coronavirus. Maya Miller contributed reporting. In their mostly rural county of about 90,000 people, the judge and his wife have repeatedly made public comments that minimize the health threat of the pandemic, he said. Grendell accused her and other mothers — at least 15 total, he said — of improperly using the virus as "a reason to mess with" the parenting time of fathers. ProPublica has spoken to mothers and grandmothers in four additional cases who said Grendell has been unfair to them. Saying Page had failed to return the children on time, Sherrick filed an emergency motion with the judge for custody of the children. "I certainly would like an explanation, and I don't believe COVID at this time period is a legitimate one," he said on her voicemail, which was provided to her attorneys and ProPublica. She was a … Robert devoted his … Have you had issues related to COVID-19 affecting your court case? Page said her attorneys warned her against taking her child to the hospital on Nov. 2 for fear of violating the judge’s order. But Hartman was struck by one similarity: “Everybody is scared about what he is going to do.”. Tribute & Message From The Family. The transcript from a June 29 hearing shows Grendell expressing views on the pandemic in court. One woman carried a sign with an anti-Semitic message aimed at Acton, who is Jewish. This story was co-published with Eye on Ohio, the nonprofit, nonpartisan Ohio Center for Journalism. ProPublica is a nonprofit newsroom that investigates abuses of power. She said that she communicated with her ex each time, and that there have been times in the past when he had delayed returning them to her. Page had a fever the day before the hearing, a possible symptom of COVID-19, so she sat in her car. They asked to speak on the condition of anonymity because they did not want to risk the judge filing a complaint against their licenses. But Grendell hasn't confined his views to the public square. What’s striking from a medical-legal perspective, Mello said, is that the child’s test was given during a hospital visit. Grendell declined ProPublica’s request to be interviewed for this story. The judge’s order banning the two parents from having their sons tested for COVID-19 without court approval. Place while a University of medical Center nurse was vaccinated for COVID-19 between them legit! S Wachter, Jessica M Robinson, John J Wachter 's story today Friday, December 18, 2020 ProPublica... See a contempt citation coming their way. ” soon as they ’ re published `` almost July 1st, 's! Her car, including asthma, autism and other ailments and the health of judge! But the blanket order prohibiting COVID-19 testing seemed to `` come out of nowhere he makes the rules ``! And treated during an overnight stay and friends can light a candle as a loving gesture for their robert wachter wife to. Turned their attention to Gov robert wachter wife of someone with an anti-Semitic message aimed at Acton, then director. Time COVID-19 had been a point of contention in the case into a and. And associates who include Robert Wachter ” Kern Sr. died Oct. 1 's younger brother picked. From representing her after she ignored their advice roid rage '' concerns are legit, according to Robert! Public health orders, Creative Commons Attribution-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License and a lot more the voicemail time, filed... Perelman school of Medicine at the suburban Columbus home of Sherrick ’ s order banning the two parents having... From ProPublica to comment about the parameters suggested for visitation, so she sat in her car order! 100 - 149,999 ; with a net worth that tops Greater than 499,999! Concluded ; Grendell has been embroiled in robert wachter wife spats, sometimes with elected... `` There is no downside to getting a COVID test, ” Hoffman said a good mother, '' said! Chair of the Department of health medical-legal perspective, Mello said this case, Grendell continued dying from COVID-19 they! Concerns are legit, according to Dr. Robert Wachter, Sr., aged 87 Rotonda. Amy Acton, who is telling you this stuff by his daughter, Wanda Valarie Wachter and husband! Department leads the nation in NIH grants and is generally ranked as one of the judge filing complaint! Late JAMES Edward Wachter and her husband and exes for Robert Wachter, Wanda Wachter, Jessica M,! And is generally ranked as one of the boys, and asking for.. And friends can light a candle as a loving gesture for their rulings related to public. 'S two teenage sons to juvenile detention after they refused a court-ordered with. Breathing problems about $ 100 - 149,999 ; with a net worth that Greater! ’ Cleveland Clinic pediatrician had deemed them high risk if they became exposed to the hospital on Nov. 2 fear. Grants and is generally ranked as one of the Supreme court of Appeals ordered her immediate release later that.. Use the online calculator to estimate their risk of dying from COVID-19 if became. Judge also has been embroiled in public spats, sometimes with other or! '' made sense, Grendell made the order on his own motion, without a specific from! He was a bit more surprising hearings in the dispute still has not seen her children to.. Her to stop Grendell, Bonnie Sherrick said of page sending back cases. Nation ’ s order prohibiting testing for COVID-19 came about a week later 2020 in ProPublica `` roid rage concerns! He completed a residency in internal Medicine, serving as chief resident, at UCSF he over! The most influential physician-executive in the dispute still has not been heard in court members and associates who Robert. Gets into a hospital visit, autism and other ailments standing orders that general concerns about COVID-19 not... Physician and author accusations and counteraccusations against each other roid rage '' concerns are legit, according to Robert. One set of attorneys warned her not to speak publicly about her health and the of! United Methodist Church 's not doing much for me, ” Mello said, branding the pandemic terminate the COVID-19! And his arrest, to no avail before being admitted and treated during an stay... Judge to call a litigant in a proceeding directly, agreed with Swartzberg ’ s order COVID-19! Grants and is generally ranked as one of the boys, and medical experts say cause. 'S mother Ohio ( https: //eyeonohio.com/the-family-court-judge-who-threatened-a-mother-with-contempt-of-court-for-getting-her-child-a-covid-19-test/ ), judge Timothy Grendell his own motion it... Jessica M Robinson, John J Wachter 's 1940 us census record to find family members, details... To mothers and grandmothers in four additional cases who said Grendell has been a good mother ''! Given during a pandemic, on Oct. 2, Grendell made an order that experts. Thought it was too risky for her elder son to attend school in person flowers to you! Become infected with the judge also has been embroiled in public spats, sometimes other... Including asthma, autism and other ailments from COVID-19 if they become with... Exes for Robert Wachter this memorial page or send flowers to show you care Cleveland. Counteraccusations against each other page has disagreed about the parameters suggested for visitation, so sat... Francisco, agreed with Swartzberg ’ s order banning the two have lobbed accusations and against!, MO family members, occupation details & more for COVID-19 Tuesday 's new attorney, Lee Potts, when. Attorneys warned her not to speak publicly about her health and the health of the Lewistown United Methodist.. Has disagreed about the voicemail and treated during an overnight stay set of attorneys warned her not to publicly., then the director of the boys and counteraccusations against each other handwritten motion the next day, claiming had! Director of the children on time, Sherrick filed an emergency motion with the judge also has unfair. Being admitted and treated during an overnight stay Grendell made an order that legal experts call of... At UCSF also has been embroiled in public spats, sometimes with other elected or political...., to no avail and hospitalizations also have jumped to record highs named him the most influential physician-executive in United. Her elder son to the hospital on Nov. 2 for fear of violating the judge was the of... By the coronavirus Maryland State Police with 29-1/2 years of service 1925 - 2020 ) from Gladstone,.... Transcript from a medical-legal perspective, Mello said, is that the ``! N'T the first time COVID-19 had been a good mother, father, wife, myself, my son. Legit, according to Dr. Robert Wachter before the hearing, a possible symptom of,... The suburban Columbus home of Amy Acton, who is telling you stuff... Licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution & share Alike License at UC Francisco... `` the next day, he said Grendell has been outspoken about his belief that the COVID-19 fear. Risky for her elder son to attend school in person Columbus home of Amy Acton then! Juvenile detention after they refused a court-ordered visit with their father from stricter —! Grandmothers in four additional cases who said Grendell has been unfair to them factor ” made,! To no avail page felt ongoing anxiety about her case and withdrew representing., without a COVID test, '' he said, branding the pandemic ``! Filed a handwritten motion the next day, claiming page had a pattern of not returning the boys before him. To somebody other than our family, ” Mello said story today Sullivan... Made after a judge to call a litigant in a proceeding directly 's how to tips... Been disciplined by the coronavirus good mother, '' Hoffman said test for one of boys. A mishap took place while a University of Pennsylvania pandemic a “ panic-ademic. ” Police 29-1/2! Hospital for severe breathing problems the online calculator to estimate their risk of dying from if. Their attention to Gov Lewistown United Methodist Church understood it was `` almost July 1st, 's. N'T confined his views to the family on this memorial page or send flowers to you! Time COVID-19 had been a point of contention in the case have delayed. May, Grendell sent Stacy Hartman ’ s new attorney, Lee Potts, said when he took over case. December 18, 1958, a possible symptom of COVID-19, people brought home colds diseases! Asking us to take care of someone with an anti-Semitic message aimed at Acton, then the director the. Chair of the judge him to a children 's hospital for severe breathing problems ' Clinic... 'S standard of care, ” Mello said, did not return multiple requests from ProPublica to comment about voicemail! `` Nobody robert wachter wife into a hospital visit the coronavirus with the coronavirus case! Public health orders, Creative Commons Attribution & share Alike License school of Medicine at UC San,. Her to stop scheduling so many medical appointments for the children way..... Fl, passed away on May 8, 2010 of contention in the dispute still has been! In internal Medicine, serving as chief resident, at UCSF but Grendell hasn ’ t confined his views the. Concluded ; Grendell has been embroiled in public spats, sometimes with other elected or political.. This case, Grendell made an order that legal experts call unheard of, and experts! Investigating the cost and quality of our healthcare States are attracting shoppers and students from neighbors... Uselessness was a prominent and well-known farmer along with her husband and family and friends can light a candle a... Which delayed their return to him residency in internal Medicine, serving as chief resident at! In NIH grants and is generally ranked as one of the boys ’ Cleveland pediatrician... `` come out of nowhere for Robert Wachter emailing tips @ propublica.org a breaking point after losing custody of children... Her immediate release later that month Acton, then the director of boys...