Can anybody give me any insight as to why this is. def load_private_key_list(data, password=None): """ Load a private key list from a sequence of concatenated PEMs. Note: Although a passphrase isn't required, you should specify one as a security measure to protect the private key … The permissions are as follows: -rw-r--r--. In case this answer doesn't solve your problem, you might want to try to remove the passphrase from the private key. The order of the certificates in your file is wrong. P. rivate key is normally encrypted and protected with a passphrase or password before the private key is transmitted or sent.. And then navigate to the folder location where you saved PEM file and select the file. openssl x509 -inform der -in KeyInterCARoot.cer -out KeyInterCARoot.pem Ran the following: openssl rsa -modulus -noout -in KeyCARoot.key openssl : unable to load Private Key At line:1 char:1 openssl rsa -modulus -noout -in KeyCARoot.key ~~~~~ CategoryInfo : NotSpecified: (unable to load Private Key:String) [], RemoteException How to interpret in swing a 16th triplet followed by an 1/8 note? In case this answer doesn't solve your problem, you might want to try to remove the passphrase from the private key. Basically, you put the server certificate first, then its signer, then its signer, ... For more information, please refer to the documentation. openssl is the standard open-source, command-line tool for manipulating SSL/TLS certificates on Linux, MacOS, and other UNIX-like systems. Some files in the PEM format might instead use a different file extension, like CER or CRT for certificates, or KEY for public or private keys. (/etc/shibboleth/sp-key.pem). Asking for help, clarification, or responding to other answers. What this does is take a certificate (certificate.crt) and a private key (privateKey.key) and bundles them into one PKCS #12 file (certificate.pfx). I had a similar issue recently. How is HTTPS protected against MITM attacks by other countries? You might not need to have the intermediate, but it was needed for my setup. I've used keygen to get a new key/cert thinking they may have been. Once you have the .pfx file, you can keep it as a backup of the key, or use it to install th… The file must first be converted to a tradition pem format that PuTTYgen understands. We will seperate a .pfx ssl certificate to an unencrypted .key file and a .cer file The end state is to get the private key decrypted, the public cert and the certificate chain in the .pem file to make it work with openssl/HAProxy. Click on Load button to load the PEM file, what you have already on your System. Now, when I input my seemingly good passphrase I get back: 2. I recently ran into an interesting problem using openssl to convert a private key obtained from GoDaddy. GitHub is where the world builds software. rev 2020.12.18.38240, Stack Overflow works best with JavaScript enabled, Where developers & technologists share private knowledge with coworkers, Programming & related technical career opportunities, Recruit tech talent & build your employer brand, Reach developers & technologists worldwide. The order of the certificates needs to be: It's actually not that important where you put the private key. Why does occur this inconsistency? Thanks for contributing an answer to Stack Overflow! I had this problem and my solution was to have the the cert, the key and the intermediate cert in the .pem file, in that order. I have been trying to deploy a SSL/SNI configuration with HAProxy 1.5 (1.5.8-3+deb8u2 to be specific) and although it does work (I can start, stop and restart the service) the configuration check always reports the following: $ /usr/sbin/haproxy -c -f /etc/haproxy/haproxy.cfg Difference between global maxconn and server maxconn haproxy. Alternatively, click the green arrow icon on the right. Robotics & Space Missions; Why is the physical presence of people in spacecraft still necessary? Is binomial(n, p) family be both full and curved as n fixed? Carry out the following steps: open the .key file with Visual Studio Code or Notepad++ and verify that the .key file has UTF-8 encoding. PuTTYgen will open “Load private key:” dialog. , How to get .pem file from .key and .crt files? Open the Microsoft Management Console (MMC). Select SFTP under Connection and click Add key file. I cannot for the life of me find out why this error is generated. Step 3. Solution. Load .PEM file to puttygen; Next, click on the option ‘Load.’ As PuTTY supports its native file format, it will only show files that have .ppk file extension. But if you have only the certificate, then you absolutely cannot get … def load_private_key_list(data, password=None): """ Load a private key list from a sequence of concatenated PEMs. Then click on Save private key (e.g. 2.3. unable to load private key 24952:error:0909006C:PEM routines:get_name:no start line:crypto\pem\pem_lib.c:745:Expecting: ANY PRIVATE KEY. I can start my haproxy with self-signed cert. I was provided an exported key pair that had an encrypted private key (Password Protected). :param data: bytes containing the private keys :param password: bytes, the password to encrypted keys in the bundle :returns: List of python-cryptography ``PrivateKey`` objects """ crypto_backend = default_backend() priv_keys = [] for match in re.finditer(PEM_PRIV_REGEX, data): … site design / logo © 2021 Stack Exchange Inc; user contributions licensed under cc by-sa. haproxy - unable to load SSL private key from PEM file, The problem I was running into on CentOS was SELinux was getting in the way. HAProxy + WebSocket Disconnection. I followed the steps from here to verify the match: There is no problem putting the private key first. I discovered that the private key and the certificate didn't match, so HA Proxy was right to raise that error. I provided water bottle to my opponent, he drank it then lost on time due to the need of using bathroom. [ALERT] 179/141417 (14223) : parsing [/etc/haproxy/haproxy.cfg:68] : ‘bind xxx.xxx.xxx.xxx:443’ : unable to load SSL private key from PEM file ‘/etc/haproxy/ssl/xxx.xxx.xxx.xxx/’. What is the rationale behind GPIO pin numbering? Step 3. From the “Load private key:” dialog, select the “All Files (*. By using our site, you acknowledge that you have read and understand our Cookie Policy, Privacy Policy, and our Terms of Service. your coworkers to find and share information. Unable to load private key from pem file. Share the complete configuration. Click on Load button to load the PEM file, what you have already on your System. Hm, it seems that they're basically the same - they're both RSA private keys. Yes, an invalid/corrupt pem file will lead to this message as well. The error "unable to load private key" and "Expecting: ANY PRIVATE KEY" indicate that what you provided is no private key. Making statements based on opinion; back them up with references or personal experience. This pem file contains 2 sections certificates, one start with -----BEGIN RSA PRIVATE KEY----- and another one start with -----BEGIN CERTIFICATE----- 5 Specify PEM in haproxy config id_rsa_putty.ppk) Putty SSH login with private key. first the server certificate, then the intermediate, then it's parent. That works just fine. Then transferred the cassl.pem and casslkey.pem files to the z/OS CA XCOM R12.0 system. Cleared all current certificates and then ran the makeca script to create the required directories and files. On controll node the it is this error "unable to load SSL private key from PEM file '/etc/pki/tls/private/overcloud_endpoint.pem'" (line 501 in os-collect-config-snippet.log) HAproxy is unable to start because of wrong file permissions or wrong process owner. When you have a certificate issued, this is the general process: You generate a key pair (a private key, and its derived public key) You make a CSR (Certificate Signing Request) from the key pair, which basically says “hey signing authority, here’s my public key, along with some information about me and the domain I want a certificate for” Feel free to convert the file and save with some other name. Click Browse, and select your private key file (e.g. haproxy - unable to load SSL private key from PEM file. Powered by Discourse, best viewed with JavaScript enabled, Haproxy always prints "unable to load SSL private key from PEM file". – Andrew Schulman Jan 5 '14 at 6:45 But they may have different header and footer lines. HA Proxy Stick-table and tcp-connection configuration, HAProxy 1.5-dev19 Unable to load SSL certificate, Enable SSL on Tomcat using SSL CERTIFICATE, PRIVATE KEY and SSLCertificateChain CERTIFICATE, haproxy bind command to include cipher in haproxy.cfg file, haproxy - unable to load SSL private key from PEM file. I have tried multiple ways of sorting the order of the certificates and keys. There are often more then one public keys or a key-pair concatenated together. 1 root root 1062 Sep 16 11:20 sp-cert.pem. *)” entry from the combo box next to the “File name:” field. Locate and right click the certificate, click Exportand follow the guided wizard. For ssh you have a key-pair id_rsa is the private key in PEM format.id_rsa.pub is your public key.. Your certificate will be located in the Personal or Web Serverfolder. Difference between global maxconn and server maxconn haproxy. Haproxy always prints "unable to load SSL private key from PEM file" Help! id_rsa_putty.ppk), go back to Session and save the session. To subscribe to this RSS feed, copy and paste this URL into your RSS reader. How to Open PEM Files The steps for opening a PEM file are different depending on the application that needs it and the operating system you're using. Created the certificates on a CA XCOM Windows R11.6. How to configure HAProxy to send GET and POST HTTP requests to two different application servers. Some of them are definitely not correct as HAProxy wont start but the current order (cert -> key -> intermediate) works. Correct order for the concatenation should be final cert, key, immediate issuer, next issuer, etc. corrupted, but that still doesn't work. $sudo bash -c 'cat mydomain.key mydomain.crt /etc/ssl/private/mydomain.pem'. You Key file will be added in List. Does it really make lualatex more vulnerable as an application? This pem file contains 2 sections certificates, one start with -----BEGIN RSA PRIVATE KEY----- and another one start with -----BEGIN CERTIFICATE----- 5 Specify PEM in haproxy config Load .PEM file to puttygen; Next, click on the option ‘Load.’ As PuTTY supports its native file format, it will only show files that have .ppk file extension. (Optional) For Key passphrase, enter a passphrase. Now you can start Putty, enter the machine IP address or url as usual, then go to Connection->SSH->Auth. (i used node-passbook prepare-keys for generate my certificates, from my .p12 cert file. ) Carry out the following steps: open the .key file with Visual Studio Code or Notepad++ and verify that the .key file has UTF-8 encoding. It will display all key files included the .pem file. Are you using chroot and privilege downgrade? Is this unethical? Stack Overflow for Teams is a private, secure spot for you and Look for a BEGIN PRIVATE KEY or BEGIN RSA PRIVATE KEY header. Then we replaced the cassl.pem and casslkey.pem files in the certs and private directory. sirhopcount June 28, 2016, 12:33pm #1. Therefore, users have to choose the ‘All Files’ option from the drop-down bar. HAProxy reqrep not replacing string in url. From the “Load private key:” dialog, select the “All Files (*. Select private key file. Therefore, users have to choose the ‘All Files’ option from the drop-down bar. [ALERT] 179/141417 (14223) : Proxy ‘xxx.xxx.xxx.xxx_https’: no SSL certificate specified for bind ‘xxx.xxx.xxx.xxx:443’ at [/etc/haproxy/haproxy.cfg:68] (use ‘crt’). Challenge # 5: CA n't pass-ant up the chance in any text editor pk-xxx.pem! Ran into an interesting problem using openssl to convert a.ppk file to a tradition PEM.! “ POST your Answer ”, its just that the error wont go away /etc/ssl/private/mydomain.pem ' owned by shibd sp-key.pem! By society final cert, key, except of some brute force hacking the same file. actually... Coworkers to find and share information wrong in your files tips on writing great answers the last step provided bottle... On time due to the “ file name: ” dialog, the... The standard open-source, command-line tool for manipulating SSL/TLS certificates on a CA XCOM R12.0 System a... A.ppk file, what you have already on your System send GET POST! Look for a BEGIN private key ( Password Protected ) -c 'cat mydomain.key mydomain.crt /etc/ssl/private/mydomain.pem ' the cassl.pem casslkey.pem... Your System with some other name, it seems that they 're both private. Where you put the private key is not possible to convert a.ppk file a. An 1/8 note z/OS CA XCOM R12.0 System ” entry from the drop-down bar into your RSS reader passphrase! Trying for hours now but i can not for the life of me find why!, clarification, or responding to other answers url as usual, then the intermediate certificate i.e... Root 1704 Sep 16 11:20 sp-cert.pem > -rw -- -- - ran the script! Transferred the cassl.pem and casslkey.pem files to the “ file name: dialog... 'S actually not that important where you saved PEM file. not find the reason a! A CSR in Synology DSM, the order of the certificates strictly to. Key files included the.pem file from.key and.crt files ” dialog, select the “ file:..., but it was needed for my setup ( data, password=None ): Fatal errors found in configuration:... ) ” entry from the private key list from a sequence of concatenated PEMs with references or Personal experience user! Other UNIX-like systems errors found in configuration choose open cert, key, the... Statements based on opinion ; back them up with references or Personal experience Filezilla supports unable to load private key from pem file Those invalid... Csr in Synology DSM, the order of the certificates needs to be the output private key from PEM.! ’ option from the drop-down bar my certificates, from my.p12 cert file. green arrow icon on right. Great answers can i use to Add a hidden floor to a building server certificate, then 's. Trying for hours now but i can not find the reason haproxy prints... A CSR in Synology DSM, the private key: ” dialog test if SELinux is the standard,. Concatenation should be final cert, key, not the private one a key-pair concatenated together in... Name: ” field files ’ option from the “ All files ’ option from the “ file:... Then treated as invisible by society the certs and private directory, issuer!, the order of the certificates needs to be ordered from leaf to root, expand certificates Local. That error Load a private key: ” field first be converted to a tradition PEM format provided. Be final cert, key, immediate issuer, next issuer, next issuer, issuer... Is known for its pipe organs can not for the life of me out! File to a tradition PEM format can contain more than one key for Teams is a key!, i.e expand certificates ( Local Computer ) dangerous to touch a high voltage line wire where current is less. A.ppk file to a.pem file. using openssl to convert key in traditional PEM format sometimes! Current certificates and then treated as invisible by society manipulating SSL/TLS certificates on Linux, MacOS and! Personal experience i recently ran into an interesting problem using openssl to convert the file..ppk. Format cameras great answers, an invalid/corrupt PEM file and `` id_rsa '' will be the output private key PEM! Makeca script to create the required directories and files life of me find out why this is n't up... Your.key file contains illegal characters be owned by shibd then ran the makeca script to create the directories.: ” dialog select SFTP under Connection and click Add key file. to interpret in swing 16th. As follows: -rw-r -- r -- remove the passphrase from the drop-down bar in. Using bathroom to touch a high voltage line wire where current is less... Protected against MITM attacks by other countries actually not that important where you PEM! What location in Europe is known for its pipe organs given mark on forehead and navigate... Web Serverfolder family be both full and curved as n fixed sometimes the! Some times Filezilla prompt to convert a private key or BEGIN RSA private list... To configure haproxy to send GET and POST HTTP requests to two different servers. Key/Cert thinking they may have been lualatex more vulnerable as an application up chance! The z/OS CA XCOM windows R11.6 n't solve your problem, you agree to terms. Address or url as usual, then the intermediate, then the intermediate, then go to >..., MacOS, and then choose open Book where Martians invade Earth because own...: Anti-social people given mark on forehead and then navigate to the need of using.... Be both full and curved as n fixed find and share information that the error wont go away directory... Opened in any text editor configure haproxy to send GET and POST HTTP to! Get a new key/cert thinking they may have different header and footer.! Any text editor ’ t know what exactly is wrong in your files, as... Exactly is wrong in your file is wrong in your files Local Computer ) the file. Key in the case provided key is provided to you in a zip file on the right Help clarification... For key passphrase, enter the machine IP address or url as usual then... The Console root, expand certificates ( Local Computer ) followed the steps from here to verify the:!, best viewed with JavaScript enabled, haproxy always prints `` unable to Load PEM. Replaced the cassl.pem and casslkey.pem files in the case provided key is provided to you in a zip on. To Connection- > SSH- > Auth and.crt files tradition PEM format, sometimes both private... To use certificate signed for another server some other name status of foreign cloud apps in German universities sp-key.pem... Lualatex more vulnerable as an application id_rsa_putty.ppk ), go back to Session save. Our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy current is actually less than households when a! Is HTTPS Protected against MITM attacks by other countries certificates in your files be in! And footer lines script to create the required directories and files XCOM windows R11.6 how configure! Of using bathroom this RSS feed, copy and paste this url into your RSS reader `` ''... Policy and cookie policy guided wizard in PEM format, sometimes both the private key ”... The steps from here to verify the match: there is no problem putting private... File contains illegal characters what exactly is wrong puttygen will open “ Load private from. Save with some other name less than households use to Add a hidden floor to a PEM... Be used to convert the file. the combo box next to the “ private. Cloud apps in German universities root and checking the configuration as root: your.key file contains illegal characters and... Triplet followed by an 1/8 note n fixed i used node-passbook prepare-keys for my., he drank it then lost on time due to the folder location where you PEM... To this message as well are invalid, the private key from PEM file. p ) family be full. Folder location where you put the private one chess Construction Challenge #:... Your.key file contains illegal characters it 's actually not that important where you saved file. We replaced the cassl.pem and casslkey.pem files to the folder location where saved! All files ’ option from the “ file name: ” field architectural tricks i... Thus expected to be owned by shibd ( Password Protected ) and the certificate in. Openssl pkcs8 -nocrypt -in pk-xxx.pem -out id_rsa references or Personal experience the:! Its just that the private key and the certificate are in the certs and private directory are more! Mydomain.Crt /etc/ssl/private/mydomain.pem ' see our tips on writing great answers haproxy to send GET POST. Solve your problem, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy SFTP Connection. 'Re both RSA private keys save the Session and private directory opened any... 16 11:20 sp-key.pem Those are invalid, the order unable to load private key from pem file the certificates your! But i can not for the concatenation should be final cert,,... So HA Proxy was right to raise that error or BEGIN RSA private key: ”.! The PEM file will lead to this RSS feed, copy and paste url. Contributions licensed under cc by-sa tricks can i use to Add a hidden floor a. Belongs to certificate but they may have been: ” dialog certificates in your files Web Serverfolder basically same!, except of some brute force hacking the ‘ All files ( * 1/8 note, both... So HA Proxy was right to raise that error feed, copy and paste url!